I was moved by the article ‘Thoughts on Vegas, and Why Men Keep Doing This,’ which describes the loneliness of men and how our culture (which lacks adult play) has led to mental illness and mass shootings. Further, I’ve been following the #MeToo movement which has me convinced that every woman has, in one way, shape or form, been sexually harassed or assaulted by men.
Frankly, I’ve been bogged down, thinking: “Men–you are one fucked up gender.”
But I’ve also been thinking lately about how men have encouraged me, as I recently got a new job. [Shameless plug to connect with me on LinkedIn.] As I look back over decades of work experience, I realize how many men were directly involved in my success. I never truly thanked them, which is pathetic given how good I am about remembering birthdays and sending thank you cards.
When I worked for a startup during the dot com bubble, one of my clients, a VP of Marketing asked if I’d ever given any consideration to business school. He found me to be hard-working and analytical, and was impressed by how I put structure around ambiguity. He didn’t coach or mentor me, but it was his confidence that motivated me. I knew he was well-respected and that inspired me.
That’s one noteworthy example of many. Plus:
- Every single offer letter I’ve received was from a man.
- Every single promotion and raise was from a man.
Maybe it’s because men dominate management and leadership roles, but there have been many opportunities for female bosses to promote me and never once did that happen.
I worked for a woman who committed to match a competing offer because she knew (and I knew) that she couldn’t afford to lose me. Several months later, I brought to her attention that my salary had never been updated. She justified (essentially, lied) that I had stayed on for the opportunity, not for a wage increase. I immediately placed a call to HR and nothing could be done. I would have to sort it out with my manager. That’s the most egregious example, but not the only one, of how a woman held me down.
Nevertheless, I’m not here to glorify men.
When I was a teenager, I was assaulted by a family friend. He knocked on the door and I let him in as usual. I asked where his wife was, as she usually accompanied him; she was outside waiting in the car. He’d caught some fish over the weekend and brought some over for my parents who weren’t home. He then started flirting with me, handed over his business card, and said we should go out to lunch. I remember feeling confused, not scared. His wife was right outside for God’s sake. I was a good kid, obedient, naturally shy, but friendly. He was one of my dad’s closest friends. I might have even said ok to lunch because I was polite. I was glad when he started to make his exit, but then he grabbed me and his lips slithered onto mine. So yeah, #MeToo.
Men suck. Men aren’t perfect, but neither are women. All we can do (male or female) is keep fighting the good fight for what’s inherently right. Everyone deserves respect. Everyone deserves a chance. We are all deserving of love and play and connection.
And gratitude. I wrote this to shine a spotlight on those who typically don’t get credit or recognition because the help is subtle. I feel very thankful.
Janine Huldie
I love how you wrote this and will add my grandmother always said that there was good and bad on both sides and all around us. So, like you I try to see both sides and think you did a great job exploring that here. thanks for sharing, Catherine.
Patrick Weseman
Here is a question that I have been asking myself and I am going to use your words: “Men-you are one fucked up gender” and why are we so fucked up?
The reason I have been asking that is because my son is 20 and I feel so sorry for him as a man in this culture.
I mean, if I want to join Curves-I can’t because it is female only. They started a female-only meditation group at my work so I am not allowed (shit, they should want a male to come in and calm his soul for 30 minutes) but at work I am always told to carry a box for a female or something because it is too heavy for them.
If I started a exercise place and it was male-only or there was a male-only meditation group at work, people would be banging gongs and protesting like there was no tomorrow demanding females be let in but nobody is complain about Curves and the like.
I look at what are the role models on TV these days for men and they suck. You are either a super cool, pill-popper, racist, violent abusing alcoholic or you are a buffoon. There are no Ward Cleavers, Father’s Knows, Mike Brady out there anymore. You know the Dad’s who worked, came home and dispensed some life advice about morals and such to their children.
I am not saying that males are perfect, we are pretty messed but most of us are trying to the right thing and nobody cares as the 15% of us who are jackasses are highlighted.
I have tried to live in 85% that are decent and have tried to give my son some morals on how to treat all people and especially women. The sad thing about this is that he remains single as those who are jackass males he knows are getting all women. As one girl told him- It is nice that you have these morals but there is something wrong with you because you have them-You are not a Jesus-freak or something. Of course, she called him a couple of weeks later because she was dumped/cheated on/ who knows by a jackass and she now hates males.
Tamara
Ew, that story! Basically I think most of us rock and there are unsavory men and women.
I’m so sorry about your #metoo stroy.
Dana
You bring up many good points, Catherine – as always, I appreciate your thoughtful perspective. Your story….wow. I know we can’t separate our gender from who we are (nor should we, in many cases), but as the mother of one son and one daughter, I’m just trying to raise the best version of human beings that I can.